Bucky Brooks’ latest QB trust ranking puts Caleb Williams on top and Michael Penix Jr. at the bottom for now
NFL.com’s Bucky Brooks revisits the six first-round quarterbacks from the 2024 draft and separates present trust from long-term investment. His rankings put Caleb Williams first, Jayden Daniels second and Drake Maye third, while Michael Penix Jr. lands sixth in a split verdict on the fifth-year option.
Bucky Brooks’ latest notebook treats the 2024 quarterback class less like a draft snapshot and more like a living evaluation. That matters because the league’s most talked-about first-round passer group has already produced a wide range of outcomes, and Brooks uses both performance and contract timing to sort through the six quarterbacks who came off the board in the first 12 picks.
The result is a ranking that rewards current reliability, not draft pedigree. Caleb Williams sits No. 1, Jayden Daniels No. 2, Drake Maye No. 3, Bo Nix No. 4, J.J. McCarthy No. 5 and Michael Penix Jr. No. 6. Brooks also pairs each spot with a fifth-year-option call, which gives the piece more practical value than a simple power ranking. For front offices, that distinction is the point: the question is not only who has flashed the most, but who deserves a long-term financial commitment when the option deadline arrives.
Williams is the clearest “pay him” case in the group. Brooks points to a quarterback who has grown more efficient under Ben Johnson, including an improved completion rate from 58.1% in 2025 to 68.7% in 2026 and a passer rating jump from 90.1 to 95.4. He also notes eight fourth-quarter comebacks, plus a 16-7 record as a starter since 2025 with a division title and an additional playoff win. Brooks does not ignore the volatility — Williams has 24 career giveaways and can take too many sacks — but his verdict is decisive. The Bears have found the right fit between play-caller and playmaker, and Brooks says extending Williams is a no-brainer.
Daniels remains near the top even with durability questions hanging over him. Brooks calls him one of the most efficient dual-threat quarterbacks in league history and highlights the production that made him the 2024 Offensive Rookie of the Year: a polished passer, a dangerous runner and a player who led Washington to the NFC Championship Game as a rookie. The concern is not talent. It is availability. Daniels has already missed 12 regular-season games because of injuries, including a recurring elbow issue that ended his 2025 campaign and cost him two games in 2026. Still, Brooks’ option verdict is firm. Washington should keep him in the fold and eventually sign him to a blockbuster deal because the on-field value is too large to ignore.
Maye’s slot at No. 3 reflects both how high his ceiling has risen and how uneven the road has become. Brooks credits him with a 2025 season in which he led the league in completion percentage at 72% and passer rating at 113.5 while throwing for 4,394 yards and 31 touchdowns against eight interceptions. But the same passage underscores the warning signs: playoff inconsistency, a steep postseason drop in efficiency and a rough start to the 2026 season before a fractured fibula. Even so, Brooks still recommends exercising the fifth-year option and extending Maye before the 2027 campaign. The logic is straightforward: the tools are too rare to walk away from after one bad stretch.
Nix lands fourth, and his placement shows how Brooks weighs winning versus polish. He gives the Broncos quarterback credit for a 31-12 career record, an NFL-record 16 game-winning drives through three seasons and 13 fourth-quarter comebacks. At the same time, Brooks is plain about the limitations: a sub-90 passer rating for the second straight season and a stat line that does not match the clutch reputation. Even so, the recommendation is to extend the rookie deal. Denver’s late-game success with Nix under center makes the option worthwhile, even if the front office still has to settle on a number that reflects the broader concerns.
McCarthy and Penix occupy the bottom two spots for different reasons. McCarthy has looked sharper since landing with New York, but Brooks says the sample is too small — four games of significant action, including three starts — to justify a major fifth-year salary. Penix gets the harshest option verdict of all. Brooks praises his arm strength and deep-ball talent, but the injuries and missed time are too much to overlook, and he says Atlanta has not yet seen enough to commit to the fifth year.
Taken together, Brooks’ rankings say more than who is hot right now. They show how a team should balance upside, durability and evidence when the first-round clock starts ticking on the next contract.
Corner Wire covers MLB, NFL and NBA through its own newsroom. Send a correction.